Kodachrome Compared

I have made film simulation recipes for all three major eras of Kodachrome film. The first recipe is called Vintage Kodachrome, which simulates the look of pre-1960’s Kodachrome. The next recipe is Kodachrome II, which mimics the look of 1960’s through mid-1970’s era of the film. The latest recipe is Kodachrome 64, which resembles the final version of the film, from 1974 through 2009.

You might wonder how these settings, which all share the Kodachrome name, compare to each other. Well, I made multiple versions of the same images to see. I wanted to place them against each other to observe their differences. It’s interesting to see how they render the same scene differently. Vintage Kodachrome is the most dissimilar. Kodachrome II and Kodachrome 64 sometimes look very similar (much like the real film), and sometimes there’s an obvious difference. One reason why they might be noticeably different is because the Kodachrome II recipe uses auto-white-balance while the Kodachrome 64 recipe doesn’t. You could use warming or cooling filters in conjunction with the Kodachrome 64 recipe (much like the real film) in order to better control the white balance. I sometimes did this back when I shot actual Kodachrome, but I haven’t tried it with the recipe.

I surprised myself in that I prefer the Kodachrome 64 versions more often than the Kodachrome II. I have said many times that Kodachrome II is one of my all-time favorite recipes, but I think I might prefer the new version just slightly more. It’s a close call, though, and in certain situations Kodachrome II would probably be the better choice.  Which recipe do you prefer? Which version of Kodachrome is the winner in this comparison?

48445624642_ee68461569_c

Vintage Kodachrome

48445623722_48c29bc131_c

Kodachrome II

48417158861_e4f5b694ea_c

Kodachrome 64

48442519207_516ac50e52_c

Vintage Kodachrome

48442490862_91642e156c_c

Kodachrome II

48447972947_c73bc7f1fa_c

Kodachrome 64

48442252056_1c52210717_c

Vintage Kodachrome

48442406282_4fb4ccf04d_c

Kodachrome II

48442406517_bba8a6ddff_c

Kodachrome 64

48442240021_c2f0e159d3_c

Vintage Kodachrome

48446576872_a3fb19e566_c

Kodachrome II

48442252011_6a94386365_c-1

Kodachrome 64

48446418986_79c7662d63_c

Vintage Kodachrome

48446419416_d99a94ebe5_c

Kodachrome II

48446578472_9a361cbea2_c

Kodachrome 64

48446423076_35d76a3ebc_c

Vintage Kodachrome

48446424286_3df2bd1d3e_c

Kodachrome II

48446583142_1708a5bd0a_c

Kodachrome 64

21 comments

  1. Randy T · August 3

    Think I like the vintage the best. I used your recipe of this a film simulation currently using. TY. Of all you have created what is your favorite?

    Liked by 3 people

    • Ritchie Roesch · August 3

      My favorite? The next one. I really enjoy creating these different recipes. In all seriousness, though, I find that different ones work well for different situations, but (for color) I use my new Velvia and Kodachrome II a lot (although I will probably use the new Kodachrome recipe more). I like Kodacolor and Fujicolor Industrial a lot, as well. I’d like to play more with the “faded” recipes. Eterna is nice sometimes. It’s a hard question to answer.

      Like

    • jsam · August 5

      I’m with you. Vintage is my pick of the lot too. I was surprised to see +4 on the highlights. I’d never have been that brave.

      Liked by 2 people

  2. James · August 3

    Much needed article Ritchie. Funny enough I really like the vintage version because of the highlight control and rendering of oranges and red, the very feature that made me fall in love with Kodachrome. I think best to shoot one version one month at a time to really learn the pros and cons of each. How I wish we can bracket custom simulations.

    Anyway, would you consider creating 2 of my favourite cheap films, Fuji C200 and Kodak Ultramax 400?

    Thanks again for sharing.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Ritchie Roesch · August 4

      I do also wish that you could bracket custom settings. That would be a good feature. I have tried to create both of those films recently, but got distracted before figuring them out, so I need to jump back into them.

      Like

      • James · August 4

        Yes please! Looking forward to both. Thank you again.

        Liked by 1 person

      • Ritchie Roesch · August 4

        No guarantees that I will be successful, but I will try.

        Like

  3. Ilya struzhkov walkincircless · August 4

    I really look forward to testing 64 on the street, but it already seems to me that my beloved «II» will still be a favorite. I think this is just the perfect recipe for everything! Very versatile! (I’m thinking about switching to gfx (this is of course unlikely because of the price, but maybe .. I hope) and I think I would continue to use “II” even with this system, which I find very funny 🙂 you have 50 megapixels and you shoot in jpeg !? what !? haha! What do you think about it?)

    Liked by 1 person

    • Ritchie Roesch · August 4

      If I had a GFX camera, I would still be a JPEG shooter. I hope that you get one. The Kodachrome II recipe is indeed a special one.

      Like

  4. fragglerocking · August 4

    Too hard to choose!

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Ricardo Richon Guzman · August 4

    although I love Kodachrome II(or X) the 64 version got me more into “those colors”

    but here I’m waiting for the B/N comparison 😛

    Liked by 1 person

    • Ritchie Roesch · August 4

      I appreciate “those colors” and I definitely appreciate your feedback!

      Like

  6. jacobwixyahoocom · August 6

    Awesome and fun as usual! What do you think about the Kodak Portra 400 recipe still? Just curious lol

    Like

  7. Aycan Gonenc · August 6

    Kodachrome 64 is the best “film taste” to me so far. Thanks for coming up with this.

    Liked by 1 person

  8. Vito Paradiso · August 6

    I dont know why but the 64 is giving me more warmer photos compared to the vintage, but i really like it. And the Kodachrome II is fantastic. You made me fell in love with my Fuji once again! Can’t wait to try out the recipes next week in Sardinia!thanks again

    Liked by 1 person

  9. Khürt Williams · September 28

    I have all three of our Kodachrome recipes on my X-T2. My favourite is the Kodachrome 64. I grew up in the West Indies, where it’s always summer (there are no seasons), so perhaps I am just partial to the way Kodachrome 64 looks in warm light.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Ritchie Roesch · September 28

      I think that there’s something special about all three of them, so it’s very hard for me to pick a favorite, but the Kodachrome 64 recipe seems to edge out the others by a hair in my opinion. Thank you for commenting!

      Like

      • Khürt Williams · September 28

        That should have been “your” not “our” in that first sentence.

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s